The Penicuik Cuckoo

Top Menu

  • About Us
  • Join Us
  • Got a Story?
  • Contact Us

Main Menu

  • Homepage
  • News
  • Notices
  • Comment
  • Life & Property
  • Sport
  • Event Features
  • About Us
  • Join Us
  • Got a Story?
  • Contact Us

logo

The Penicuik Cuckoo

  • Homepage
  • News
  • Notices
  • Comment
  • Life & Property
  • Sport
  • Event Features
  • Anchor Town Centre Store to Close

  • 2 SCOTS to Parade in Penicuik

  • A702 Roundabout Works to Restart

Breaking News: Mauricewood Road Reopening Delayed Till April 30

News
Home›News›Wind Farm Developers “Deny the People of Their Democratic Right”

Wind Farm Developers “Deny the People of Their Democratic Right”

Non-determination within allocated time sees application pushed to appeal board

By Thomas Scott
October 4, 2014
1218
3

The chairman of a local environmental protection group has hit out at developers of the planned Mount Lothian wind farm, who have appealed to the Scottish Government weeks before a public meeting, forbidding public representation.

Plans for a nine turbine wind farm south of Penicuik will now be considered by the Scottish Government’s planning appeal body after Midlothian Council failed to give their decision within the allocated time period of four months.

Wind Prospect Developments Ltd and EDF Renewables are hoping to erect nine 102 metre tall wind turbines on Penicuik’s Mount Lothian, just off the B6372. The developer says that each turbine would be capable of generating 2.3 megawatts of power, with a collective sum of 20.7 megawatts being generated per year. All in all this could power 11,092 homes across Scotland.

However after submitting plans to Midlothian Council back in February, the application is yet to be formally decided upon. This is partly down to the developers themselves according to the council. The following is from the council’s appeal statement:

The council wishes to make it known that it [the application] had been prepared for determination in May 2014 however due to difficulties in arranging a pre-determination hearing (availability of the applicant, other participants, venue and council members) this had to be delayed.

The appellant was made fully aware of this at the time. Furthermore, at the time that the appeal was submitted the appellant was fully aware of the proposed schedule for determination of the application. This was for a pre- determination hearing to be held at Penicuik Town Hall on 26 September 2014, with a planning committee date of 07 October 2014.

The mentioned pre-determination meeting was cancelled after Wind Prospects appealed on 22 August, a move that has been branded as undemocratic by the Penicuik Environment Protection Association’s chair Professor Tony Trewavas:

Wind Prospect Developments Limited have twice denied the people of this area their democratic right to present their views to the Councillors at a predetermination meeting.

Whilst the predetermination meeting was cancelled, Midlothian’s councillors are set to state their position on the appeal in a planning committee meeting on October 7. The committee are set to suggest that the government moves to dismiss the application, thus refusing permission. Midlothian Council have stated that the application would have been refused, had it been down to them. Professor Trewavas continued:

The Planning Department have lodged papers which show they would have and will recommend refusal on October 7th thus Midlothian Councillors have been denied their right to determine the application.

The PEPA chair was also keen to highlight the proximity of the suggested site to two other prospective wind farm sites, both of which were refused stating:

Four Government Reporters, Local Plan Reporter, two Reporters at the Auchencorth Public Inquiry and one at the Gilston Public Inquiry have all said that this area is not suitable for large scale wind farm development.

This is the second application by the developer. A controversial application submitted in 2013 was withdrawn to allow further ecological surveys to be carried out, voiding over a thousand public representations. Since resubmission earlier this year, the application has not received as many responses with many statutory bodies not participating for a second time.

Wind Prospect Developments want to stress the benefits of a community fund which could generate millions of pounds over its lifetime. A substantial amount of the money generated would be used on improving the Penicuik Estate, according to land owner Sir Robert Clerk.

The Scottish Government’s reporter will carry out a site visit and take into account all submitted representations to date when they make their decision later this year.

What’s you view? Should the development go ahead? Is it a blight on the landscape? Let us know your view below.

TagsEnvironmentMidlothian CouncilPenicuik
Previous Article

West Midlothian Has an Infrastructure Problem

Next Article

Police Patrols Increased After Housebreakings

Thomas Scott

Editor and founder of The Penicuik Cuckoo. Fourth year Architecture student (MA Hons) at Edinburgh University currently writing on the role of architecture in post-industrial towns. Interested in all things Penicuik. Triplet.

  • Where’s a

    Any attempt to bypass democratic determination and the rights of the people affected should be dismissed immediately, wind farms today, Fracking tomorrow, think on.

  • Farmer Bill

    Typical wind farm developer ploy. Appeal should be dismissed and they should be made to re apply for planning permission (and pay fees again) and allow local democratic decision to be made (which they will then appeal of course if it goes against them).

  • Shirley Sheyes

    Don’t be taken in with Professor Trewavas’ concern for the environment – he’s a mouthpiece for the fossil fuel industry. My opinion here: http://shirleysheyes.wordpress.com/2014/03/05/where-does-the-windfarm-hot-air-come-from/

Timeline

  • November 4, 2018

    Anchor Town Centre Store to Close

  • October 2, 2018

    2 SCOTS to Parade in Penicuik

  • August 23, 2018

    A702 Roundabout Works to Restart

  • June 12, 2018

    Roundabout Works Halted by Crummock Collapse

  • January 12, 2018

    Mauricewood Roundabout Works Begin

Advert

  • Terms of Use
  • Comment Policy
  • Cookies
  • Our Publications
© The Penicuik Cuckoo, 2017